
Compare · Park vs park
Canyonlands vs Black Canyon of the Gunnison
Which one to visit, or how to see both. They’re about 3 hr 35 min (197 miles) apart by road.
The short answer
- Our rankingWe rank Canyonlands #35 and Black Canyon of the Gunnison #49 of the 63 parks we have visited. More
- CrowdsBlack Canyon of the Gunnison is the quieter park: 250,086 visits in 2025, against 796,057 at Canyonlands (about 3 times). Source
- SeasonBoth are at their best in May, September and October. Canyonlands is also good in March and April. Black Canyon of the Gunnison is also good in June. More
- Both?It’s about 3 hr 35 min by road (197 miles) from Island in the Sky Visitor Center to South Rim Visitor Center, our estimate with no stops. Doable on one trip if you give each park its own days.
Side by side
Sources: the park guides (National Park Service pages, linked on each guide), NPS entrance fees, NPS visits for 2025, our best-months scores (dark = better), and today’s NPS alerts as of Nov 20, 2026. Drive times to airports are our road estimates with no stops.
In our words
CanyonlandsOur #35
Canyonlands is huge, and the Green and Colorado rivers split it into districts. Island in the Sky is the one you can see in a day. We watched sunrise through Mesa Arch and found ancient stone granaries tucked under a sandstone ledge.
Our favorite hike: Mesa Arch. It’s a short, easy walk to an arch on the edge of a cliff that frames a huge view of the canyons below.
Black Canyon of the GunnisonOur #49
The canyon is dark, narrow and so deep that sunlight barely reaches the bottom. The Painted Wall is the tallest cliff in Colorado, and its streaks of pale rock look painted on. It’s not crowded, and you can see a lot in a day.
Our favorite hike: Warner Point Trail. At the end of the South Rim Road, this 1.5-mile round trip looks straight down into the gorge and out to the San Juan Mountains.
From David & Keri New, who have visited 63 of the 64 national parks. How we rank them.
Seeing both
It’s about 3 hr 35 min by road (197 miles) from Island in the Sky Visitor Center to South Rim Visitor Center, our estimate with no stops.
Go in May or September or October to catch both at their best.
- Plan a trip to both free itinerary builder
- Canyonlands guide camping, hikes, when to go
- Black Canyon of the Gunnison guide camping, hikes, when to go
- Where to stay near Canyonlands lodges, towns and rentals
- Where to stay near Black Canyon of the Gunnison lodges, towns and rentals
Questions
- Which is better, Canyonlands or Black Canyon of the Gunnison?
- It depends on your trip. In our own ranking of the 63 national parks we have visited, Canyonlands is #35 and Black Canyon of the Gunnison is #49.
- How far is Canyonlands from Black Canyon of the Gunnison?
- It’s about 3 hr 35 min by road (197 miles) from Island in the Sky Visitor Center to South Rim Visitor Center, our estimate with no stops.
- What is the best time to visit both Canyonlands and Black Canyon of the Gunnison?
- May, September and October, when we rate both parks 4 or 5 out of 5 for weather and access.
More matchups
- Arches vs Canyonlands under an hour apart
- Capitol Reef vs Canyonlands about 3 hr apart
- Canyonlands vs Mesa Verde about 3 hr apart
- Bryce Canyon vs Canyonlands about 5 hr apart
- Arches vs Black Canyon of the Gunnison about 3 hr apart
- Mesa Verde vs Black Canyon of the Gunnison about 4 hr apart
- Great Sand Dunes vs Black Canyon of the Gunnison about 4 hr apart
- Capitol Reef vs Black Canyon of the Gunnison about 4 hr apart
Neighbors within a 5-hour drive, plus a few well-known pairs farther apart, from our road estimates of Nov 10, 2026 (routing data © OpenStreetMap contributors). Or compare any two parks.