
Compare · Park vs park
Redwood vs Crater Lake
Which one to visit, or how to see both. They’re about 4 hr 20 min (220 miles) apart by road.
The short answer
- Our rankingWe rank Redwood #12 and Crater Lake #23 of the 63 parks we have visited. More
- CrowdsCrater Lake is the quieter park: 632,242 visits in 2025, against 1,202,480 at Redwood (about 90% more). Source
- SeasonBoth are at their best in July, August and September. Redwood is also good in May, June and October. More
- CostRedwood has no entrance fee. Crater Lake charges $30 per vehicle, good for 7 days.
- Both?It’s about 4 hr 20 min by road (220 miles) from Thomas H. Kuchel Visitor Center to Steel Information Center, our estimate with no stops. Doable on one trip if you give each park its own days.
Side by side
Sources: the park guides (National Park Service pages, linked on each guide), NPS entrance fees, NPS visits for 2025, our best-months scores (dark = better), and today’s NPS alerts as of Nov 20, 2026. Drive times to airports are our road estimates with no stops.
In our words
RedwoodOur #12
These are the tallest trees on earth, and they make you feel tiny. We saw banana slugs and fern-covered canyons, and the fog only makes it feel more like a different world. Wear shoes you don’t mind getting wet for Fern Canyon.
Our favorite hike: Boy Scout Tree Trail. We hiked it on our first trip, in 2018.
Crater LakeOur #23
The water is a blue you don’t believe until you see it. Seeing the lake for the first time is a favorite memory of ours. It’s the deepest lake in the US, and it sits in a collapsed volcano.
Our favorite hike: Cleetwood Cove Trail. Cleetwood Cove was the only trail down to the water, and we took a boat trip to Wizard Island from there.
From David & Keri New, who have visited 63 of the 64 national parks. How we rank them.
Seeing both
It’s about 4 hr 20 min by road (220 miles) from Thomas H. Kuchel Visitor Center to Steel Information Center, our estimate with no stops.
Go in July or August or September to catch both at their best.
- Plan a trip to both free itinerary builder
- Redwood guide camping, hikes, when to go
- Crater Lake guide camping, hikes, when to go
- Where to stay near Redwood lodges, towns and rentals
- Where to stay near Crater Lake lodges, towns and rentals
Questions
- Which is better, Redwood or Crater Lake?
- It depends on your trip. In our own ranking of the 63 national parks we have visited, Redwood is #12 and Crater Lake is #23.
- How far is Redwood from Crater Lake?
- It’s about 4 hr 20 min by road (220 miles) from Thomas H. Kuchel Visitor Center to Steel Information Center, our estimate with no stops.
- What is the best time to visit both Redwood and Crater Lake?
- July, August and September, when we rate both parks 4 or 5 out of 5 for weather and access.
More matchups
- Redwood vs Lassen Volcanic about 4 hr apart
- Sequoia vs Redwood about 9 hr apart
- Crater Lake vs Lassen Volcanic about 5 hr apart
Neighbors within a 5-hour drive, plus a few well-known pairs farther apart, from our road estimates of Nov 10, 2026 (routing data © OpenStreetMap contributors). Or compare any two parks.